Clicky

Op-Ed: What’s Happening on the Mindy Project is Not Okay – The Feminist Wire

Op-Ed: What’s Happening on the Mindy Project is Not Okay

By Nashwa Khan

I used to love The Mindy Project. I would buy a pint of ice cream, drop all my work on Tuesday nights, and cancel plans with other people. It would be Mindy and me in my dorm room. I would watch repeat episodes, loving an unapologetic South Asian woman on screen. And I saw myself in parts of Mindy. But living in a mainstream feminist echo chamber, we become accustomed to never questioning those we idolize.

Before realizing the show’s problems with sexual consent, I had noticed the anti-blackness, which caused me to disengage from my Tuesday night ritual. Having avoided every episode of the third season, I thought I would give Mindy another chance. Clicking through channels recently, I came across an episode that ended in disappointment, regret, and frustration.

The episode, entitled “I Slipped,” was disgusting and triggering, to say the least. Years have gone by without Kaling’s body of work being critically examined regarding the issue of sexual consent. Her fan base is largely young and feminist, and thus reoccurring flaws in The Mindy Project’s handling of consent is disturbing.

This particular episode centered around a scene early in the episode, as Danny and Mindy are having vaginal intercourse. The audience hears the dialogue during the scene and it sounds pleasurable and consensual — up until you hear Mindy exclaim, “Wait, wait! Danny, that doesn’t go there!” And here, a red flag should go up. And this red flag should be cemented upon hearing Danny’s character reply, “I slipped” instead of offering an apology.sexual consent

Now, as an audience member one can deduce that Danny had anally penetrated Mindy without her consent. This is troubling because the Mindy we have grown to love is depicted as a strong female character. How the situation is handled throughout the episode echoes normalized rape apologist behavior. With a young female audience admiring The Mindy Project, this discourse is a slippery slope, normalizing nonconsensual acts in a sitcom. It signals that it’s okay to accept this behavior and to perpetuate it in real life.

Every sexual act requires consent. The notion that, in relationships, consent is automatic is not only wrong, but also incredibly dangerous and disingenuous.

The episode gets more cringe-worthy as Mindy and Danny discuss the incident the next morning. Danny asserts it was accidental, saying “You weren’t where I was. You didn’t see how it all went down.” This discourse of non-apologetic assertion as an accident is eerily reminiscent of manipulative and abusive behavior by partners.

As Mindy seeks advice from her coworker Peter, viewed as a “dudebro,” he insists to Dr. Lahiri that there is no way the nonconsensual act was an accident. Instead of watching Mindy have an epiphany or condemn the act, we see her question her own sexual performance and experience. This is largely seen in broader society when victims interrogate themselves and their own choices because of rape culture.

Mindy sits down with Peter to hear sex tips she might use to please Danny, again another moment where a great conversation about consent in relationships is overlooked in favor of a woman learning to appease the man who violated her.

Later in the episode, we witness more rape apologist sentiments as Danny justifies the act again by saying, “I thought you had done it before.” This is when the grey area of consent becomes black and white. The belief that women who are or have been sexually active are deserving victims of sexual assault is too real to make a joke of. This is unnerving.

Survivors often have their sexual histories used as justification for their assaults. We witness it in cases repeatedly, and rape apologists use it to justify violent acts. Danny also, again without any remorse, mentions that he “got carried away” and asserts that in the past Mindy has bragged about her sexual history. This is also a mainstay in rape culture, demonizing women specifically for sexual histories and “slut shaming” both implicitly and explicitly. The nonchalant rape apologist lines in the episode were not critically unpacked in any way.

Mindy, still in the mindset of pleasuring Danny, recruits another colleague, Morgan, to prescribe her sedatives. She places the sedatives in a glass of scotch; this part is very real for survivors who have been drugged. This scene is also too casually done: Mindy takes the sedatives as a way to desensitize herself to an act she is uncomfortable with, all in the name of ‘keeping her man.’

The sedatives create a roofie effect, which we witness in Mindy’s loss of control. Mindy must go to the hospital and there, Danny realizes what his sexual act has done to his girlfriend. Again a non-apology is issued, as Danny continues to self-assuredly justify the act saying, “It didn’t mean anything. I just tried something.” This discourse around nonconsensual acts is dangerous, and similar to the “boys will be boys” rhetoric. It erases responsibility and accountability.

Mindy’s character trivializes the experience of being drugged in this scene as well saying, it “wasn’t so bad.” For those who have survived being drugged and sexually assaulted, this is not a punchline. Especially when alcohol remains the most commonly used in drug facilitated sexual assaults. This episode ends with what I imagine to be an attempt at discussing the importance of consent in their future relationship, but ends with Danny saying “I should’ve started kissing you, asking sucks!” After their lesson at the hospital, after all the lost potential to have a meaningful conversation about consent, Mindy responds with “Damn it, you’re right!”

Perpetuated over the last two seasons of The Mindy Project are two major myths around sexual consent. First, we see Mindy as a racialized woman presumed to be sexually experienced and thereby deserving of the nonconsensual act. And second, we also witness men being placed into a category of “always wanting it” and not as possible victims of sexual assault themselves, as in the episodes where Morgan is cuffed non-consensually to a bed and Dr. Leotard is raped.

While Kaling is not the sole writer of the show, and a male writer on her staff allegedly wrote the episode about anal penetration, the series is called The Mindy Project. Having one’s name on a project warrants accountability. These episodes are small but significant instances upholding the normalization of sexual assault. Sexual acts, and intimate acts overall, need consent at every step.

___________________________________

The Mindy project and sexual consentNashwa Khan identifies as South Asian/African Diaspora living and learning in Hamilton, Ontario. She calls Florida home. Over her undergraduate career in Hamilton, she served on a number of councils including the City’s Status of Women Committee, as Space Allocation Chair of McMaster’s Women and Gender Equity Network, and currently chairs the city’s Youth Advisory Council. Her work has been published in a variety of places including ThoughtCatalog, Guerilla Feminism, and the HuffingtonPostBlog. She is an avid storyteller and lover of narrative medicine. Feel free to tweet her @nashwakay. Nashwa has attended a number of workshops around public health, feminism and creating queer friendly spaces. Most recently she attended the Columbia Narrative Medicine Workshops.

8 Comments

  1. Vaso

    November 3, 2014 at 2:56 pm

    Dear Nashwa,

    Thanks for posting your excellent critical commentary. I really urge you to submit a summary of your arguments to the New Yorker as a letter to the editor. They recently (maybe 2 weeks ago) published an article about the provocative feminist agendas the Mindy project promotes and heralds it as a leader in this regard on primetime. I think your article (rightly) contradicts the entire premise of that commentary piece and would be a superb response. Hope to see it in there!

    VR

    • Nashwa

      November 4, 2014 at 12:51 am

      HI VR,

      Thank you for the comment. I really appreciate it. Is this the article you are referring to: http://www.newyorker.com/culture/cultural-comment/female-bad-fan ? I just want to make sure I read the right article.

      Thank you so much for taking the time to comment.

      Nashwa

  2. SJ

    November 3, 2014 at 7:55 pm

    This is AWFUL! (not your article, what happened on the show) it is just slut shaming, and rape apologising! This is such a damaging thing for young women to be seeing when they should be learning about proper consent!

  3. A

    November 3, 2014 at 8:25 pm

    I’m so glad you brought this up. As a rape victim the show rubbed me the wrong way, but I felt bat criticizing one of the few shows that offer any semblance of representation. I’m extremely disappointed and I’ve also seen her comments afterwards defending such episodes. I’m upset that in favor of being quirky instead of strong. I also hated her line in one of the promos when she says “I’m not that kind of Asian” when having sex with Danny. The way it’s phrased makes it okay to treat other asian women in a fetishized way.

  4. Lun

    November 4, 2014 at 1:58 am

    I don’t think I agree with your reading of that episode. That episode was obviously about consent but if you watched the other episodes of this season you will realize that basically all of the characters are making outrageously ill-conceived and misinformed statements that are nowhere within premises of the political correct. I think she has taken the Silverman route this season where she does and says things so ludicrous that the comedy happens when the audience realizes how insane her acts really are. I think she is pointing out that her insecurities sometimes get the better of her judgement and that while the situation is not okay, it does not condemn her to be a complete failure (which often happens to victims wondering how they could have “let” someone hurt them). I admit, the episode does require the audience to look and listen more carefully and it is especially difficult because Mindy’s character is so likeable as opposed to the usual, obvious stooges but I really don’t think she is apologizing rape. I do think that it shows that while her character is feminist, she is not an infallible goddess but a human who also makes bad decisions. I think Mindy is very ambitious in the sense that she is trying to pack comedy with feminism while addressing difficult topics without preaching and through a nuanced lens. If she is really succeeding is another topic but I urge you not to condemn her so quickly.

    • Nashwa

      November 4, 2014 at 4:55 pm

      Hey Lun, You can definitely not agree with my take on it but I am going to let you know that I still think the reading of the episode is accurate. I specifically did a play by play to establish it as not a hasty reading of the episode. The episode may have been about consent but how it was done matters, as well this is not the first time and I do make reference to that. I also don’t think I ever cited complete failure on her end so sorry if that is how it was interpreted. She has definitely been successful in many aspects of her work. I want to move this away from Mindy and back to the show because I think this became a defence of Kaling whereas I really wanted to establish that the show has a consent problem that is reoccurring. I also do point out that it is a problem regarding who is deemed worthy of consent. If the show and I emphasize the show were attempting to show what you describe there are ways to do it better. I actually think this is a great conversation to be had because I really would not consider her character a feminist. I also do not expect that as a default because she is a woman. I think she is a strong female character but definitely not a feminist character. That also is not on her and i also have seen her cite that it was not the intention. Beyond this there is an antiblackness problem on the show so to be entirely honest I have a hard time weighing what she succeeds at over what is really flawed. Thank you for your insight, this is a worthy conversation to be had.

  5. A

    November 5, 2014 at 10:46 pm

    Dear Nashwa,

    Thank you for this post. As a person who’s been in similar situations many times your article was helpful in some ways but sort of triggering in others.
    Sometimes I think the phrase “ignorance is a bliss” is quite accurate and these commentaries kind of remind me of it. I get passionate about these issues a lot as well, although I am not sure if it makes me any happier.
    The issue of consent is indeed a problem; unfortunately a lot of things are taken as granted. Guys claiming they accidentally “slipped” or that they thought their partner would think something was hot, without asking for their approval is almost encouraged and considered “manlier.” I am not sure why this show is hailed as a feminist piece of work since I don’t think it is, and I do agree with you on it being anti-black and I think it is anti-minority is many ways (Mindy only dates white guys by the way).
    Sorry about the lengthy comment but like I said, sometimes it feels better not to know or think of things too critically because of all the negative feelings it induces, especially when we look back on past experiences of abuse and consent.

  6. Olivia

    November 9, 2014 at 7:28 am

    I thought this episode was distasteful and your analysis proves it was a mistake. Great work! very well spoken and to the point of the truth!