Clicky

The Limits of Speaking on Catastrophe: Confessions of a Palestinian Teacher – The Feminist Wire

The Limits of Speaking on Catastrophe: Confessions of a Palestinian Teacher

By Diya Abdo

I am a Professor of English at Guilford College.

I am Chair of the English Department.

I am a faculty member in the Women’s, Gender, and Sexuality Studies Program.

I am also a Palestinian.

More specifically, I am from Arab Al-Sawahreh.

My tribe is so big that its name, The Sawahreh Arabs, appears as a location on some maps of Palestine (and there are many of this relatively small country). We live on Jabal Al-Mukabber, one of the Mounts of Jerusalem – “the mount of he who calls out the greatness of god.”

I remember time spent there as a child – stone houses lining narrow dusty streets, doors unlocked, cool paved staircases leading to cool paved rooftops, dozens of little feet running through rooms and across roofs.

Now, a wall runs through it.

One part of my tribe has been divided from the other. Sometimes the same family is separated from itself.

From the house where I grew up in Amman, Jordan to Jabal Al-Mukabber in Palestine, it takes 45 minutes. 45 minutes less than it would take us right now to get to Raleigh, or Durham, or Chapel Hill.

Did my grandmother know when she left with her two children because of the occupation that those 45 minutes would turn into 12 hours at King Hussein Bridge? Did she know that those 12 hours would turn into impossibility when, time after time, she applied for a visa at the Israeli embassy, and was denied, time after time? Did she know at 37 (almost my age now), that at 75, when she wanted to see her sisters, those 45 minutes would turn into never and forever?

She died of cancer in a Jordanian hospital, having never returned.

My uncle was a Fida’i, a Palestinian Freedom Fighter. Exiled out of Jordan after Black September and unable to go back to Palestine, he loitered in a large waiting room called the world – sometimes Pakistan, sometimes Saudi – until King Hussein finally “forgave” the Feda’yeen.

21 days ago, my relative Mohammed was killed in a hail of bullets in Jerusalem. The Israelis say he was going to ram his van into a busload of Jewish settlers; his family says he was just driving by and a spooked settler shot him.

So what do I say about Gaza on this small campus in Greensboro, North Carolina, 6,000 miles from Palestine?

At least, we do not have Anna Akhmatova’s problem.

Anna Akhmatova was a Russian poet whose husband had been killed and son imprisoned by Stalin’s regime. Terrified of causing more harm to her son, but determined to live out the role of the poet as witness and as memory, she wrote a poem entitled Requiem. Here are some of the first lines of that poem:

In the terrible years of the Yezhov terror, I spent seventeen months waiting in line outside the prison in Leningrad. One day somebody in the crowd identified me… and asked me in a whisper… “Can you describe this?” And I said: “I can.” Then something like a tormented smile passed over what had once been her face.

Still afraid her poem would be discovered and her son punished even further, Akhmatova burned all of her poems, including Requiem, but not before she had her friends commit them to memory. There was no other way to preserve this witness. One of the friends remembers “going out late at night into the empty streets repeating a poem to herself over and over again, terrified she would forget a word or get something wrong.”

But we do not have Akhmatova’s problem. We are all witness. The images of Gaza bombard us.

A friend of mine shows me on her iPhone happy pictures of her visit to Ramallah, Palestine, this summer, her kids playing in the gardens of grandparents. Her thumb slides softly over the screen, and every once in a while, interspersed among the images of her smiling children, a mutilated corpse of a Palestinian child appears – images, no doubt, downloaded to her gallery through Facebook or What’s Up – thousands upon thousands of “likes” and “shares” and “posts.” Her thumb passes lightly over them; we don’t say a word about these images.

We are witness to so much. And not just in Gaza – in Iraq and Syria and Ferguson.

So what can I say about Gaza?

As an Arab woman, raised Muslim, I have often had to choose between competing selves. Sometimes, even small daily moments call for putting my Arabness ahead of my womanhood, or my womanhood before my Arabness, or my Muslim identity ahead of both.

Always, however, I am a teacher. Teaching is my passion. It is my vocation. It is the place where my divided selves are salved – where I can reconcile being an Arab and being a woman. My nationalist self comes to terms with my feminist self because I can intellectualize this division and make it a teachable moment for my students.

So what can I say about Gaza?

I have nothing for you but my confession:

Today, it’s hard for me to be a teacher. Today, I am a divided being. My teaching self is at odds with my Palestinian self. This is very problematic, even to me: I dwell in the life of the mind; intellect and theory are my daily bread.  But I have seen dark glimpses of this and always tried to pretend it away. On the rare days I teach Palestinian literature, a deep nausea and melancholy settle in my body and soul in a way that is all but debilitating.

This is not a teaching moment for me, except that it teaches me that perhaps there are limits to intellectualizing catastrophe. In the face of death, in the face of rivers of blood, in the face of hungry children and lifeless hospitals, sometimes horrified silence and righteous anger are what are called for.

And here, too, is my confession:

When I envisioned Guilford’s response to “Protective Edge,” it did not look like this discussion panel. I envisioned it like a clear line drawn in the sand, like that story a former professor of mine at Drew University told me about the Quaker board of Trustees of Bryn Mawr, who after the bombing of Cambodia, shut down the College and cancelled classes and told the students to go out in the world and work for peace.

And here, too, is my confession:

At this moment, I don’t want to teach about Palestine so that others may take a stand; I want to take a stand that teaches others.

In planning this panel, as we struggled to create a safe space for our students, all I could think about was that large, unsafe, deadly prison of besieged people. What blue shirted person(1) does a Palestinian child seek when they are not feeling safe? The UN’s?

The missiles find them there as well.

As we struggled to create possibilities for dialogue, opportunities for learning, potentialities for peace, all I could think about were the little strewn bodies of impossibility, the never would be’s, the finality of death.

As we struggled to honor our students, all I could think about were those little bodies that drew their first breath in Casts of Lead, learned to read in the shadows of Pillars of Clouds, and were finally silenced by a Brother’s Keeper or the sharp blade of a Protective Edge.(2)

Who keeps and protects these children now?

On a daily basis, I walk into a classroom with very clear pedagogical goals in mind; chief among them is that my students should leave with more questions than answers.

So here, too, is my confession:

Today I want you to leave with more answers than questions.

  • Palestinian lives are not disposable.
  • Defending the self should not entail collective punishment of the other.
  • No, Palestinian lives are not disposable.
  • The Palestinian people are not their political organizations.
  • And no, Palestinian lives are not disposable.
  • Palestinian mothers and fathers want their children to live, and laugh and play and go to school. They don’t want them to strap a bomb to their chests and shatter their parents’ hearts instead.
  • Again, Palestinian lives are not disposable.
  • American tax dollars should go to feeding our hungry, not feeding missiles that brutally stop the hunger of besieged human beings 6,000 miles away.

Today I have to choose between being a Palestinian and a teacher. So I choose to be a Palestinian, but I hope you can see that by taking a clear stand, I can be both. Because I hope that intellect is not diametrically opposed to activism. That it need not distract us from action, nor be a soothing substitute for action. I hope we don’t feel better about ourselves that we have come together on this hallowed ground, where Quakers have taken a clear stand against great inequities and risked great peril to their lives and property,(3) and talked things through.

And even if this choice does mean that I have failed as a teacher – in my bones, I can live with myself as a Palestinian. 

 

The original version of this essay was delivered as a talk on the panel “Perspectives on Gaza: Israel, Palestine and the Ghosts of Catastrophe” held on the campus of Guilford College in Greensboro, North Carolina on August 28, 2014.

Notes

1. Audience members were encouraged to seek out Guilford College’s Conflict Resolution Resource Center volunteers in the blue shirts if they needed a private and safe space to express their feelings.

2. The names of various Israeli offensives against Palestinians.

3. The woods of what is now Guilford College were part of The Underground Railroad.

____________________________________

confessions of a palestinian teacherDiya Abdo is a first-generation Palestinian born and raised in Jordan. She loves teaching and writing about the work of Arab women writers and Arab and Islamic feminists. She is an Associate Professor of English and current Chair of the English Department at Guilford College in Greensboro, North Carolina.

11 Comments

  1. George Haeseler

    September 11, 2014 at 10:43 am

    I commend you for speaking out. I, too, have a conundrum. I can speak out and have spoken out publicly, the same as you, against the Israeli atrocities against the Palestinians, but I cannot broach the subject with one of my daughter and her family because, as Jews loyal to the state of Israel, they are offended. It only causes them to rebut with the standard pap put out by the Zionists and AIPAC. I am urged by other children to remain silent within our family in order not to cause disunity. Any suggestions?

    George Haeseler

    • Sofia Smith

      September 12, 2014 at 11:33 am

      George; I commend you for the position you take and that you have spoken out publicly. This is so important. As to family dynamics; I have faced similar issues on a variety of subjects within my family. I don’t back down when it’s an ethical, moral…a human issue. Most times it’s about politics for me. My family has had to deal with it. Unity does’t mean much if it’s based on cracked foundations.

  2. A Badre

    September 11, 2014 at 12:10 pm

    Your loyalty and love for your family should not stop you from standing for your moralities, should you have any.

  3. Natalie Ortega-Davis

    September 11, 2014 at 3:10 pm

    How small the world is. I saw this on a fb post from my niece who knows you and I was so pleasantly surprised she had this connection. For the past 2.5 years my husband and I have had the privilege and pleasure of living in Ramallah, Palestine and have had our eyes opened at how horrible it has been for the past 60 years for the Palestinian people to live in the open air prison called the West Bank. Palestine and Palestinians will always hold such a special place in our hearts and we will continue to let the outside western world know what a beautiful, undisposable people they are. Blessings on what you do, what you express, and who you are.

  4. David Frazier

    September 12, 2014 at 8:49 am

    War is Hell! Too many losses on both sides. The issues that need to be discussed to heal the breach between Israel and Palestine cannot be addressed as long as Hamas and other terrorist organizations are allowed to exist. Israel has the right, and must, defend itself at all costs, even at the expense of human lives. The Iron Dome has protected Israel from thousands of missile attacks from Palestine. Thank G-d. I wish Palestine had taken donated monies and created a better system of protection for its people instead of building tunnels that cost millions of dollars in an attempt to sneak in and kill Israeli’s. I hurt for the innocent Palestinians whose lives have been taken or destroyed by terrorist organizations because they used schools and highly populated areas to launch missile attacks, but wonder when Palestinians, in and out of Palestine, will band together to overthrow Hamas instead of continuing to fill the ranks of this Hate Group that only seeks destruction. Palestinian lives are NOT disposable and neither are Israeli lives. Emotional pleas only keep hate alive and make progress impossible. We must support Israel to keep democracy alive in the Middle East. A two state solution is the answer to peace and equity. Religion has been high jacked on both sides. I hope reason and humanity will replace Rabbi’s and Imam’s who continue to preach right of return and the destruction of the infidel. God…are you listening?

    Frazierdd

  5. kh

    September 13, 2014 at 1:25 pm

    I applaud you stating that the Palestinian people are not their political organizations. I agree, your lives are not disposable… nor are the Israelis. The sad truth is that Gaza is entirely political, and that unless and until a majority of Palestinians tell their leadership ENOUGH, the cycle of madness will continue. Israel wants to live in peace. Will the Palestinians recognize the state of Israel and agree to live in peaceful co-existence? Sadly, no.

    • Art Brennan

      September 16, 2014 at 8:56 pm

      The sad truth is the Israel is not interested in peace and wants to own or control all of the land that rightfully belongs to its long time residents and owners, the Palestinian people. The US supports Israel in its continuing campaign of terror, theft and murder. The rest of the world is very aware of this, but for now US military and economic influence has permitted this tragedy to continue. We in the US should be ashamed of ourselves for permitting our government to continue in its support for tin horn autocrats and puppets wherever “US interests” are at stake. Free Palestine! Boycott Israel.

  6. s

    September 15, 2014 at 6:56 pm

    I agree whole heartedly with a lot of what you said. However, American tax dollars should go to feed America’s hungry before anyone elses.

    • D

      September 15, 2014 at 8:47 pm

      Yes, that’s the point this essay makes as well. “Our” here refers to the American hungry as opposed to those “6,000 miles away.” The essay was given as a talk on an American campus and the essay is addressing that audience. “Our” here refers to Americans.

  7. Elana Wesley

    September 16, 2014 at 4:28 am

    We have the same problem with relations with our son. No talking about ‘Politics’ is allowed. Things came to a head when he called what his father and I were each accused of speaking and sending out ‘poison’. Now we are trying for a truce that would allow us to at least say when we feel it’s called for: Not all Jewish Israelis feel that way/support that position. What is considered ‘politics’ can include genetically modified organisms or the Bible saying that the land of Israel was bequeathed solely to the Jews without taking into consideration the ‘problem’ that there were also others living here. So we can either spend time with them being frightened all the time and unhappy or we can give up on spending time with our son, his wife, and his two children.

  8. Wagih Abu-Rish

    September 16, 2014 at 7:26 am

    It is said that regardless of one’s historical, social and/or cultural attributes, it takes a sense of belonging to confirm one’s ethnicity. As such, stating your sense of belonging is not only necessary but essential to promote such feeling of belonging.
    Unfortunately, we Palestinians have to affirm our being and belonging all wrapped in expressions of pain, for pain is an expression and reflection of our reality.
    Never the less, it has to be done, confirmed and repeated at every juncture, especially when it is beautifully stated and honestly depicted.
    Thanks for sharing your feelings.