Obama's (Black?) Mama

August 8, 2012
By

As Barack Obama campaigned for the presidency in 2008, critics charged that he was not “black” enough – that is, that his ancestry did not lead back to US slavery. As the son of a Kenyan man and white American woman, he was assumed to know little about black American lives. But now it appears that our president does have at least one slave ancestor…on his mother’s side. Yes, his mother’s side. The white Kansas woman turns out to be (at least in terms of the one-drop rule) a black woman passing as white.

Researchers have traced Obama’s mother’s family to a slave named John Punch who lived in 17th century Virginia. Punch had a relationship with a white woman, with whom he had children. Those children (and their descendants) passed into white society, obscuring their African ancestry.

If Obama’s mother’s ancestry is traced to a black male, and if we adhere to the one-drop rule, then there is now no question about Obama’s “blackness”: he is “African American” via both his father and mother. And his ancestry is complicated – including Europeans as well as Africans –which makes him just like other American black people.

But the news of Obama’s ancestry tells us something else: the racial divide that has characterized so much of our history did not start with the first European colonist. And racism – including the violence that historically besieged any black man accused of sexual relations with a white woman – is not an inherent human trait. John Punch was not prevented from having children with a white woman. As far as we know, the woman and their children did not suffer unduly because of their connection to an African man. In fact, they became free, white landholders in early Virginia.

On the other hand, Punch was punished for trying to escape indentured servitude. His punishment included whipping and enslavement for life. Historians believe this was the start of slavery as it came to be known in our nation. Whether the enslavement of John Punch was the start of US slavery is not the most important idea. What is important is that his life demonstrates that we (or our ancestors) created the racial hierarchies that plague us today. And anything that was created can be uncreated.

Many people have looked to Barack Obama to solve our racial problems or as a symbol of our racial progress. If we take the lessons of his ancestry to heart, they may be right.

Tags: ,

4 Responses to Obama's (Black?) Mama

  1. Veronica on August 21, 2012 at 9:54 am

    I appreciate this article, just because I find the racial debates surround Obama quite interesting. However, he is still a person of mixed racial heritage, even if his mother isn’t “pure” white. He is still going to be considered “not black enough”, and I say this as person of mixed racial heritage who struggles with this issue in the black community myself. This really saddens me.I don’t think anyone’s racial experience, no matter HOW they got to be a person of color, should be discounted as not being “enough”.

  2. Veronica on August 21, 2012 at 9:54 am

    I appreciate this article, just because I find the racial debates surround Obama quite interesting. However, he is still a person of mixed racial heritage, even if his mother isn’t “pure” white. He is still going to be considered “not black enough”, and I say this as person of mixed racial heritage who struggles with this issue in the black community myself. This really saddens me.I don’t think anyone’s racial experience, no matter HOW they got to be a person of color, should be discounted as not being “enough”.

  3. Veronica on August 21, 2012 at 9:54 am

    I appreciate this article, just because I find the racial debates surround Obama quite interesting. However, he is still a person of mixed racial heritage, even if his mother isn’t “pure” white. He is still going to be considered “not black enough”, and I say this as person of mixed racial heritage who struggles with this issue in the black community myself. This really saddens me.I don’t think anyone’s racial experience, no matter HOW they got to be a person of color, should be discounted as not being “enough”.

  4. Veronica on August 21, 2012 at 9:54 am

    I appreciate this article, just because I find the racial debates surround Obama quite interesting. However, he is still a person of mixed racial heritage, even if his mother isn’t “pure” white. He is still going to be considered “not black enough”, and I say this as person of mixed racial heritage who struggles with this issue in the black community myself. This really saddens me.I don’t think anyone’s racial experience, no matter HOW they got to be a person of color, should be discounted as not being “enough”.

Follow The Feminist Wire

Arts & Culture

  • Remembering and Honoring Toni Cade Bambara Sanchez

    Sonia Sanchez: What are we pretending not to know today? The premise as you said, my sister, being that colored people on planet earth really know everything there is to know. And if one is not coming to grips with the knowledge, it must mean that one is either scared or pretending to be stupid.

  • Hunger Kwame Laughing Foto

    They say you had the eye; they say you saw
    into people. They say you came before as shaman
    or bruja and returned as priestess; they say you were
    stonebreaker. But for me, you were a big sister
    feeling for a lonely brother with no language
    to lament, and you gave me more days, and
    more days. Yes, they could have called you
    Grace, Bambara; they could have called you that.

  • Stroller (A Screenplay) Black families and community

    Roxana Walker-Canton: Natalie sits in her own seat in front of her mother and looks out the window. Mostly WHITE PEOPLE get on and off the bus now. The bus rides through a neighborhood of single family homes. A BLACK WOMAN with TWO WHITE CHILDREN get on the bus. Natalie stares at the children.

Princeton University Post Doc: Apply Now!